Oh Glee, it’s hard to believe that it’s been three years since you graced us with a rendition of a forgotten Journey hit and captured the attention of the nation. At first, you started out with a diverse cast and a razor-sharp satirical wit that seemed more suitable for Showtime than on the same network that cancelled Arrested Development. Of course, then record and FOX executives got their paws all over you, and turned you into a glossy, castrated marketing machine of tours, sleeping bags, and lunchboxes. Congratulations, you became the TV equivalent of the Backstreet Boys. In its wake, you’ve put us through insane plotlines involving imagined pregnancies, teachers stuffing pot in lockers of students, and that time when Quinn got into a monster car accident, only to gloss it over in the following episode by being all “oh yeah, that happened. Let’s sing!!” Which is what I’m pretty sure what you do with your entire plot structure of Problem of the Week Big Message Episodes.
Not to get all high and mighty, but I knew this would happen. FOX has a habit of taking hold of a success and turning it into a juggernaut that it shoves down our throats until we develop TV bulimia. Ryan Murphy has never has an idea that stayed good for more than 20 minutes (see: Every season of Nip/Tuck after season 2; Running with Scissors; Eat Pray Love). And one time Murphy alluded to his story plan for Glee, saying it was “like Rocky” in the sense that it was going to take a long time to become national champions. I figured three seasons, and they’d win the championship, just in time to graduate. And now here we are. The Glee kids won nationals, and now a bunch of them are about to graduate and stay BFFs in Forever Magic TV Land where friendships and eternal high school love never dies. I always said that I’d stick it out until the kids graduate and win nationals. Now that time has come, and I’m ready to sign off.
My roommate said it perfectly while watching a touching moment in the Nationals episode last week. “Aw, that’s sweet. Man, this show is shit.” Even when the show peaks with a great song, it falls backwards on its awkward plot points and beleaguered storytelling. Stories I’m sick of, mostly because they make no sense. Like the time when all the kids got addicted to Vitamin D. Or how that Sugar Motta girl has been around for a whole season but never talks. She’s just, there. Or like how Will Schuester asked Finn to be the Best Man at his wedding, because apparently no adults on this show have real friends of talk to one another. Or like the time when Finn got inspiration from a grilled cheese sandwich that looked like Jesus. JESUS. THERE WAS A WHOLE EPISODE DEVOTED TO A GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICH IN THE VISAGE OF JESUS. JESUS CHRIST. AS IN CHRISTIANITY’S VERSION OF THE SAVIOR OF MANKIND. THIS WAS A REAL EPISODE OF TV THAT PEOPLE WATCHED AND IT HAD SONGS. SONGS!!! ABOUT A GRILLED JESUS!!! Somebody kill me.
But this post isn’t supposed to be all bad. Glee had a lot worth celebrating, from Sue’s touching relationship with her sister with Downs Syndrome, to their fearless tackling of homophobia and bullying. While a whole lot went wrong, there were certainly some things that went right. So to celebrate, below I have included my 10 favourite songs from the past three seasons of Glee. While nothing short of the 4th season creative resurgence of Lost will bring me back, it’s nice to remember the fun memories the show gave us (Also, apparently part of your “creative renaissance” is to team up with Horse Woman and Penny Lane, two people who haven’t done anything decent in nearly a decade. This does not bode well). So until they start using flashforwards and kill off Rachel Berry in a plane crash, I tip my graduation cap to those Glee kids and bid adieu.
Read More